It's Time To Let Star Trek Die

TL;DR

Star Trek should be cancelled because Secret Hideout's decade of failed shows has destroyed the franchise beyond repair.

Key Points

• 1.Starfleet Academy flopped completely: failed to chart on Nielsen ratings, crashed out of Paramount's own top 10 within weeks, and the free YouTube premiere got fewer views than an average video from this channel
• 2.Defenders argued fans should give the show positive reviews to prevent cancellation — the creator calls this insane, arguing bad products must be criticized or studios have no incentive to improve
• 3.Secret Hideout and Alex Kurtzman have spent nearly a decade producing Star Trek content without growing the fanbase, increasing cultural relevance, or making Paramount a single dollar in profit
• 4.The creator argues the real Star Trek spirit died 20 years ago with Enterprise's cancellation, with only the final season of Picard offering any nostalgic glimpse of the original franchise's quality
• 5.The proposed solution: shelve Star Trek entirely for 10–15 years to let Kurtzman-era wounds heal, rebuild fan nostalgia, and allow a completely new generation of writers to take creative control